Go to content
Skip menu
Skip menu

First the strategy, then the channels - not the other way around

The market starts with the channel: "Use Google Ads, we'll make the best of it." A strategy starts with the goal and only then asks which channels can carry it at all. This page shows the path from the goal to a defensible channel mix – the selection and prioritization that happen before the first dollar. For SMBs that plan themselves, and for agencies that run this process for their clients.

Why "channel first" burns budget

The channel reflex skips the selection

Whoever starts with the tactic – "we need TikTok now" – never asks whether the channel fits the overall system. They fight a symptom instead of choosing the portfolio. That is media buying, not capital allocation: money is spread across channels before anyone knows which ones together serve the goal.

Budget burned in the dead zone

Every channel needs a minimum investment of time and money to have any effect at all – a ramp-up threshold. Below it, the budget largely fizzles out. Whoever runs too many channels at once, each with too little budget, keeps them all under the threshold: a lot of money flows, but no channel carries. That is exactly what happens when the selection is missing.

How strategy development works

  1. Gather candidates. Bring together ten to twelve fundamentally possible channels – digital and offline – and sort out the ones that don't fit strategically or that you don't want to run yourself. That saves effort before the analysis begins.
  2. Research the data. For the remaining candidates, obtain the KPIs and benchmark ranges – reach, rates, costs. Halo effects, cannibalization and saturation limits are researched and entered here, not invented by the tool – by hand or via the AI function (BYOK), marked yellow and checkable.
  3. Compute. Bring each candidate into the model with its ramp-up time (the dead zone), its saturation, the halo relationships and cannibalization – on the basis of the researched assumptions.
  4. Choose the mix. Set several combinations against each other as plans and see which mix best serves the goal under your assumptions. Often the result is: cut channels, don't add them – so the remaining ones clear their threshold.
  5. Commission deliberately. With the validated mix, buy specialists or agency partners – not with the question "what should we do?", but with the brief "channel X with KPI Y in this overall system".

here to research the solid KPIs and benchmarks per channel: source overview

Set up candidates and compute the mix that carries: try the tool

A worked example

Illustrative example with assumed values – no benchmarks, no promise. It shows the logic, not your numbers.

A service provider wants to distribute a budget of around 100,000 across three channels: Google Search Ads (reacts fast, saturates early), LinkedIn (high entry threshold, but more potential later on) and trade events (small audience, saturates quickly). Three ways, the same budget:

  • Even split – a third each. Convenient, but blind: one channel is long saturated, another is only just clearing its threshold, the third is overfilled. Much of the effect fizzles out.
  • Too many channels – the dead-zone trap. The same budget additionally spread across six channels. The channel with the high entry threshold gets too little, stays in the dead zone and brings almost nothing – money burned.
  • Targeted mix – channel cut. The weakest channel is set to zero, its budget lifts the highest-potential one over its threshold into the steep range. The same total, noticeably more result.

The lesson, independent of the concrete numbers: eliminating channels often brings more than adding them, because it frees budget to lift the remaining ones over their threshold. And without halo and cannibalization in view, you systematically misjudge individual channels.

What this path brings – for SMB and agency

  • Capital allocation instead of media buying: you distribute budget by effect on the goal, not by channel reflex.
  • Independence from fads: the mix follows your goal, not the hype of the quarter.
  • A defensible brief: you commission specialists with a clear KPI in the overall system – instead of having to ask them what to do.
  • For agencies: the same process becomes a traceable consulting service that guides the client from the first conversation.

Common thinking traps

  • Expecting the "optimum" from the tool. The model computes the mixes you assemble and shows their consequences – it doesn't search for the best mix itself. The choice stays your decision.
  • Reading halo and cannibalization as measured truth. Both are researched assumptions from benchmarks and experience, not a measurement on your data. The model computes them consistently, it doesn't prove them.
  • Skipping the selection. Whoever computes right away without sorting out first models channels that were never in question – and loses time on options with no strategic basis.

Frequently asked questions

Why start with the strategy instead of the channels?

Every channel needs a minimum investment to work. Spreading a budget across too many channels can keep all of them below that point. Starting with goals and selecting channels deliberately avoids this.

How many channels should I compare?

Start with a broad list of candidates, exclude those that do not fit the strategy, and model the remaining ones. Removing a channel often helps more than adding one.

Does YourValidator find the optimal channel mix automatically?

No. You define the mixes and assumptions; the tool calculates the consequences. Comparing several scenarios shows which mix holds up under your assumptions.

Are halo effects and cannibalisation measured?

No. They are assumptions that you enter and can change. The tool shows what follows from them, not whether they are true.

What should come out of the process?

A deliberate channel selection with clear assumptions and target metrics, which can be used as a brief for an agency or internal team.

Back to content
Application icon
YourValidator Install this application on your home screen for a better experience
Tap Installation button on iOS then "Add to your screen"